Toshiba 46L5200U vs. LG 47LM6700 Comparison Shootout
Mid Priced Level LED TV Shootout: LG vs.
by Robert Wiley
The LG and Toshiba models in this shootout review have very similar features and pricing. There is no 3D compatibility in either model, but they do contain the latest Internet TV suite from their respective manufacturer. Both also contain a 120Hz refresh rate, advanced picture setting menus, and the latest edge-lit LED backlighting. Though this comparison is based on the 46/47" sizes, it applies to the 55" and 40" models as well.
HD Picture Quality
The HD picture from the LG 47LM6700 is a little soft at the edges with film based material but otherwise has very realistic color. Color information is more subdued than with many LED TVs but this is not necessarily a bad thing unless you're watching sports. Colors popped more on the Toshiba 46L5200U and image edges were a little more crisp. However, there were screen uniformity and side angle viewing issues that offset.
Advantage: Draw
SD Picture Quality
Due to the excellent processor built in the Toshiba 46L5200U we felt the picture was more crisp and detailed on the 46L5200U as the Cinespeed processor did a better job of upconverting signals from 480 resolution (except for side angles).
Advantage: Toshiba 46L5200U
Side Viewing Angle
Contrast degrades at only 20 degrees off center on the Toshiba 46L5200U. The LG 47LM6700 has one of the best viewing angle performances we've seen on an LED backlit LCD TV. It almost compares with plasma TVs in this regard. In 2012 LG has improved their louvered screen development even more to help them create less glare and better contrast from the sides in the 47LM6700.
Advantage: LG 47LM6700
Dark Shadow Detail
Turning the Brightness control up on the 46L5200U greatly enhanced dark shadow detail, however it introduced background light uniformity issues. Otherwise, both TVs exhibited very average dark shadow detail.
Advantage: Draw
Video Processing Engine
The 46L5200U processor with Toshiba's new Cinespeed processor performed exceptionally well in our processor testing. The processor will clean up nasty motion artifacts and mapping patterns caused by vertical or horizontal lines in your picture.
Advantage: Toshiba 46L5200U
Color Rendition
Color reproduction information was solid with both TVs. We thought the LG did a slightly better job due to the ability to calibrate using the 10 point white balance scale, however the picture was little softer.
Advantage: LG 47LM6700
Audio Quality
This category is easy to judge. It's always tough for these thin LED TVs to produce good sound quality. However, Toshiba has re-engineered their sound quality through an outside company called Audessey for 2012. The sound is much better than before and trumps the LG in this category.
Advantage: Toshiba 46L5200Us
Design and Appearance
Both TVs are fine in the looks department and both are super thin, and both get a new makeover this year with thinner bezel designs, but the LG 47LM6700 has the Cinema Screen design that shows little more than .2” frame and has the nice “window” effect.
Advantage: LG 47LM6700
Internet Options:
Though both TVs have the requisite Netflix, Facebook, Vudu, You Tube, and other more prominent Internet Services, LG's 47LM6700 Netcast has a few more options and proprietary Apps though neither has the most impressive choices in this area. The LG has Twitter, NBA and AP, while Toshiba carries Yahoo! Widgets. These choices change frequently so we can only judge what is available at this present moment. One big advantage for the LV5500 is a full web browser which can be easily controlled by the Magic Wand remote control.
Advantage: LG 47LM6700
Remote Control and Menu Functionality
The Toshiba 46L5200U has the better choice of preset picture modes with excellent pre-settings Movie 1 and Movie 2 and the Sports mode will really amplify the picture. The calibration picture setting options are also very complete, however the remote is not backlit. The LG 47LM6700 also has great choices in the picture calibration settings area with a full 10 point white balance scale. It also has one of the coolest features on any TVs from this year in the Magic Wand remote control, which you will prefer using to the full remote (the TV comes with both) after just a few minutes use.
Advantage: LG 47LM6700
Extra Features
The LG 47LM6700 has that great Magic Wand remote control (plus the complete regular remote) plus a full web browser and Internet Feature.
Advantage: LG 47LM6700
Value/Price
As of this publish date the Toshiba 46L5200U costs $1199 at authorized Internet dealers while the LG 47LM6700 costs $1349. There are a few more goodies included with the LG and if prices were equal we would give it the edge.
Advantage: Toshiba 46L5200U
Overall Category Wins
Toshiba 46L5200U – 4 Wins0
LG 47LM6700 - 6 Wins
Draws: 2


